Thinking and talking about rugby every day for 50+ years
2 January 2015
People often ask me ‘what was the greatest game you ever saw?’ As a young reporter I used to say it was the magical King Country v Hawkes Bay game for the Ranfurly Shield in Napier in 1968 (Colin Meads’ King Country team just got pipped by Kel Tremain’s Magpies by 19-16; 8 tries in the game! – a real thriller!) (To put that into perspective for you, you ought to know I had been born in Te Kuiti and King Country was then ‘my’ team!) But nowadays for my ‘bestest’ game I always go back to the glorious memory of the All Blacks v South Africa game in Pretoria in 1996. There was so much at stake that day and the game more than matched its expectations.
THIS IS HOW I WROTE ABOUT IT FOR "NEW ZEALAND RUGBY WORLD" a few years ago.
HOW THE GAME PLAYED OUT: The game was part of five tests between the two great rivals in seven weeks in 1996. Each of the tests in that series was a game of the highest order of rugby expression and physical commitment. Four of the tests were played in South Africa and after winning the first two there New Zealand fans at home sensed there was chance the Sean Fitzpatrick/John Hart All Blacks could become, if they played at their utmost, the first team to beat the previous year’s world cup winners in a full test series on South African soil.
At the end of one of rugby’s most dramatic afternoons the All Blacks won a truly great game by 33-26. Each of the 51,000 in the crowd at Loftus Versfeld Stadium had-been well-versed beforehand in the ‘meaning’ behind the result so the noise and tumult never died. The last moments when the All Blacks hung on grimly and denied attack after attack from the Springboks became for me the most exiting rugby I had ever commentated.
WHAT MADE IT SPECIAL: The day before the game I had ‘called a meeting’ with my co-commentator, that proud Otago man Wayne Graham, in my room. I outlined to Wayne how I, as a kid, had avidly followed the 1956 tour of New Zealand by the mighty Springboks of that year. I detailed to him the excitement engendered by that tour and how the little nation of New Zealand roared its approval, when on my tenth birthday, the All Blacks clinched the first ever ‘home’ test series win on Eden Park. It was best birthday present ever.
I also told Wayne about Peter Jones’ great try, of the massive 62,000 crowd and of Jonesy’s ‘speech’ to the crowd afterwards in which he reflected that he was absolutely ‘buggered.’ Radio New Zealand banned the replaying of that tape for 30 years!
In other words I detailed to Wayne the importance of the game we were to broadcast in 24-hours time and how he and I must be ‘ready’ for all the drama that was bound to unfold. It was kinda like a commentator’s team talk I suppose.
MOST MEMORABLE MOMENTS: But get the video of the commentary the two of us did the next day and fast-forward through to the end. There we are; two usually dignified people, shouting our absolute nuts off as the Springboks tried to deny ‘us’ and the All Blacks their first ‘away’ test series win. ‘Hold on New Zealand! Hold on!’ we both yell over each other as Fitzpatrick, Dowd, and Zinzan Brooke - and all the rest of that great team that day - threw themselves at the repeated assaults on their line. The New Zealanders gave everything in those last moments and were rewarded when the little French referee, Patrick Robin, (who we had also been shouting at) finally blew for full time. Many of the team collapsed to the ground, totally and utterly spent.
THE CENTRAL FIGURES: Those last moments are among the most memorable of all All Black rugby from the ‘90s era. But I also cannot forget the two searing Jeff Wilson tries, the amazing dropped-goal by Zinzan Brooke (after his frenzied ‘hey hey hey!’ call for the ball from halfback Justin Marshall), and the two towering late penalty goals kicked by replacement five-eighths Jon Preston. Afterwards, locals kept saying ‘who IS that guy?’ They hadn’t seen ‘J.P’ in the New Zealand World Cup team the year before.
POSTSCRIPT AFTER MATCH AND WHAT IT MEANT TO YOU: To cap the great day several truly beautiful things happened after that game. As the All Blacks staggered off the field their non-playing touring mates paid them the ultimate homage. To a man they stood by the grandstand tunnel in their shirtsleeves and, led by Eric Rush and Jonah Lomu, they ripped off a fiery tribute haka, the only time such a thing has been done by non-players from an All Black’s squad.
Then we of the combined media crowded the narrow corridor outside the winning team’s dressing room. Eventually a widely-smiling John Hart emerged. But what was this? Instead of holding a press conference he first called for all of the New Zealand media to come forward. We were invited into the dressing room because, as Hart so warmly said to us, ‘we are all New Zealanders together today.’ We broadcasters, writers and photographers pushed past the grumbling South African media.
Inside the room I saw amazing, unforgettable things. There was no cheering or gloating, just totally fatigued All Black rugby men, limp with effort but smiling with wan satisfaction. One of the media group asked Zinzan to sign the match day programme. He wanted to oblige but couldn’t do it, his hands were still trembling and could not steady enough to write his own name. In the corner I saw the young Christian Cullen slumped in his place with tears streaming down his face. 1996 was his debut season with the All Blacks and he had contributed superbly in the game. How could he, only 20 years of age, have known the significance of the win?
All I know is that he, and the others from that beautiful rugby occasion, obviously did.
[Footnote; on August 24th 2011 a small dinner was held at John Hart’s apartment in Auckland. Present were all of the management team of that tour, except for the much-missed selector, the late Gordon Hunter. I was invited to ‘represent’ the media on the games 15th anniversary. Each person from the group had to make a three-minute recollection of the game. From the warmth of the night and the recaptured memories the evening ended with plans put in place for a full reunion for all of the team in years to come. Maybe it will be in 2016? It will be a very appropriate thing to do for one of the greatest of All Black victories.]
A hotel ruckus after NZ had beaten Wales 19-16 saw Keith Murdoch banished from the tour. He stopped in Oz and hasn't yet made it home yet!
The famous New Zealand radio commentator who revolutionised the way rugby commentary was done all over the world.
The Wellington born McCarthy had essentially an outward personality; he loved talking, and he had had time on stage as a lad in the early 1930s in New Zealand. It followed then that he was not phased by nerves when he became a rugby commentator. He broadcast his games with a style so different from the conservative way callers had been first commentated the game in Britain. McCarthy was loud and brazen not afraid to raise his voice and ‘let go’ on the air.
When he was sent by the New Zealand Government to broadcast the 1945-46 Kiwi Army rugby of Britain back to New Zealand his style fascinated the conformist BBC. They took his broadcasts and put them on their stations. They were amazed that he could engender so much excitement. The BBC wanted him to stay on. Instead McCarthy came back to New Zealand, but his style lingered in Britain. Gone were the stuffy, some might say plum-in-the-mouth callers and encouraged was the McCarthy style. The great Scottish TV commentator, Bill McLaren, recalls how, as a young fledgling radio man, he was sent by the BBC to Cardiff in 1954 to stand behind McCarthy and watch ‘how’ he broadcast a game.
Because of the high peaks of emotion surrounding the 1956 Springbok tour of New Zealand Winston’s words of description and catchphrases became the catchphrases of the New Zealand nation. His most famous call was ‘listen….it’s a goal!’ when a shot at goal was taken. He would allow the cheering of the crowd to tell the radio audience first whether a kick was on target or not.
In his time, in the 1940s and ‘50s Winston McCarthy became one of the best-known New Zealanders. He became the eyes and ears of New Zealand’s voracious appetite for listening to their All Black team on tour. It was commonly said around the country that if the All Black selectors of the time could not see every game being played each week they were influenced in their selection of test teams by what McCarthy had said on the air. His words weighed that heavily.
Which New Zealand sports broadcaster once described a tight tennis match as 'a Battle of Nutrition.'