Thinking and talking about rugby every day for 50+ years
17 November 2016
KeithQuinnRugby.com wrote to the eminent New Zealand rugby statistician Paul Neazor in an attempt to clarify the records set by the appearance of Rieko Ioane as an All Blacks test player in the game v Italy. In true style Paul has come up with a definitive list and also a comparison for the Ponsonby Club with the club with the ‘second-most’ All Blacks.
Paul has given permission to reproduce here his details of the new record set by Ponsonby District Rugby Club for ‘Most All Blacks.’
Read on...with thanks to Paul Neazor (email@example.com)
When 'Passion and Pride' was written in 1998, the Ponsonby club had produced 38 All Blacks and profiles of each were given in that book. Since then another seven Ponsonby players have gone on to represent New Zealand, and the selection of the seventh (Rieko Ioane) had major significance for the club, as that enabled Ponsonby to break a tie that existed with Otago University at the head of the nationwide list of clubs with most All Blacks.
Which club has claim to the most All Blacks is often subject to various interpretations, but if you only count a player as one of the club’s All Blacks if he was still a member of that club when he was selected, Ioane’s selection was the one that put Ponies into top spot. Back in the day it was easy to place a player, as you’d see him in club colours most weekends before the rep programme started. The lines are a little more blurred now, but there’s no possible argument about any of the six players in this chapter as all played for Ponsonby in regular Auckland competition matches. In fact I think I’m right in saying all the players on this list – both Ponsonby and University – played for their clubs in at least one year they were chosen for New Zealand, or the year immediately prior to that selection.
This topic has produced some heated debates down the years, but until Patrick Tuipulotu was chosen in 2014 the southerners held a lead that stood up to the most searching examination. A visit to the Otago University website will show a list of 68 players who represented New Zealand and who had, at some stage of their careers, played for Varsity. The players who were still with the club when selected are highlighted and, as noted, there are 44 of them. The other 24 had moved on by the time the ultimate selection call came.
Ponsonby can also claim an exaggerated list of All Blacks if it includes players like Keith Nelson, Terry Morrison, Lin Colling – all of whom had played for New Zealand before joining or, in Nelson’s case, re-joining the club but who were not chosen while playing for Ponsonby - Keith Murdoch (who had returned to Otago before his first selection) and Ron Dobson (who played for Ponsonby in 1948 but who changed clubs prior to his 1949 selection). There’s no question these men played for both New Zealand and Ponsonby – just not at the same time. Ponsonby’s list of All Blacks does include six players who were chosen for New Zealand while with Ponsonby and also while with other clubs or unions.
After full research into this matter, the following lists are an accurate picture of just how the club lays claim to 45 All Blacks, and why some other well-known names aren’t here.
Players whose entire All Black career was as a member of the Ponsonby club (39):
Dave Gallaher, Bolla Francis, Joe O’Leary, Dougie McGregor, George Sellars, Fred Lucas, Len Righton, Herman Mattson, Lew Hook, Rube McWilliams, Frank Solomon, Dave Solomon, Bill Carson, Bob Scott, Eric Boggs, Percy Tetzlaff, Johnny Simpson, Neville Black, Malcolm Dick, Ron Rangi, Bryan Williams, Peter Whiting, Andy Haden, John Mills, Mark Brooke-Cowden, Joe Stanley, Matthew Ridge, Craig Innes, Va’aiga Tuigamala, Olo Brown, Carlos Spencer, Ofisa Tonu’u, Jeremy Stanley, Ali Williams, Ben Atiga, Sam Tuitupou, Benson Stanley, Patrick Tuipulotu, Rieko Ioane.
Players who played part of their All Black careers as members of the club, and therefore are bona fide Ponsonby All Blacks (6):
Morrie Wood (a Ponsonby All Black in 1904 only; previously with Wellington and Canterbury), George Nicholson (1907; previously with City club), Bill Cunningham (1907-08; previously with two clubs in the Thames area), George Gillett (1907-08; previously with Canterbury), Bert Palmer (1928-29; afterwards with Otahuhu club), Troy Flavell (2006-07; previously with North Harbour).
Players who appeared for Ponsonby but left before winning All Black selection: James Barrett, Greg Burgess, Ron Dobson, Isitolo Maka, Keith Murdoch, Keith Nelson, Kevin Senio, Joe Warbrick.
All Blacks before coming to the club, and who did not gain selection while with Ponsonby: Noel Bowden, Lin Colling, Jasin Goldsmith, Terry Morrison, Keith Nelson, Tim O’Connor, Rex Orr.
Since the subject is bound to come up, let’s also examine the Otago University register of All Blacks, using the same criteria. Because the club was, for much of its existence, a closed one and players had to be enrolled at the University to play for the light blues, many moved to other clubs quite young even if they would rather have stayed. That said, the student body at Dunedin was generally older than at the other universities due to the post-graduate courses offered, especially in health sciences. A number of the club’s All Blacks were therefore in their early- to mid-20s, rather than somewhere between 19 and 21.
Until 1950 or so many only appeared in first-class rugby for a short time, retiring upon graduation to concentrate on their professional lives. Therefore only one player, Tony Davies, was an All Black before arriving but a lot won selection after leaving. Davies was an interesting case, as he was chosen for the 1960 South African tour as an Auckland player but changed his enrolment to Otago during the year; when he came back he played one match for Auckland as a University of Otago representative and therefore became one of the first ‘loan players’. The University ranks don’t contain many players who had long international careers like several Ponsonby All Blacks; the widely different make-up of the clubs told against that and Chris Laidlaw and Earle Kirton are anomalies in the Varsity ranks. The University All Blacks are:
Players whose entire All Black career was as a member of the Otago University club (35):
Colin Gilray, Donald Macpherson, Jock Cuthill, Phillipe Cabot, Frank Ward, Billy Fea, Robert Sinclair, Arnold Perry, Edward Stewart, Abe Munro, Donald Dickson, Donald Stevenson, Dave Lindsay, Nick Bradanovich, Tubby Holden, Monty McClymont, Ron Bush, Jim Watt, Colin Gillies, Trevor Berghan, Ian Botting, Graham Moore, Des Oliver, Mark Irwin, Howard Levien, Tuppy Diack, Earle Kirton, Graham Sims, Terry Morrison, Paul Sapsford, Marc Ellis, Pita Alatini, Simon Maling, James Ryan, Adam Thomson.
Players who played part of their All Black career as members of the club, and are therefore bona fide University All Blacks (9):
Ron Elvidge (shifted to Union club for 1950), Tony Davies (chosen in 1960 as an Auckland player), Keith Nelson (later Clutha), Chris Laidlaw (Canterbury in 1968), David Kirk (later Auckland), Mike Brewer (later Kaikorai and then Canterbury), John Timu (later Taieri), Arran Pene (later Taieri), Anton Oliver (later Tokomariro),
Players who appeared for University but left before winning All Black selection: Eric Cockroft, Bob Black, John Tanner, Ross Wightman, Jim Fitzgerald, Robin Archer, Lindsay Townsend, John Buxton, Hugh Burry, Kit Fawcett, Wayne Graham, Kieran Keane, Greg Burgess, Warwick Taylor, John Drake, Brent Anderson, Rob Gordon, Jamie Joseph, Ant Strachan, Josh Kronfeld, Taine Randell, Sam Harding, Sam Broomhall, Tom Donnelly.
Three players – Keith Nelson, Terry Morrison and Greg Burgess – had associations with both clubs although none of them are true Ponsonby All Blacks. Despite this, Nelson is widely known as a Ponsonby identity and had strong family links to the club even before his own massive contribution is considered; he is a Life Member but only won national selection while in Otago. Morrison also played more for Ponsonby than for University but his brief All Black career was over before he arrived in Auckland, while Burgess didn’t win All Black honours from either club and was picked as a Takapuna man in 1980.
Played at Sydney Cricket Ground on this day. NZ won 22-3. They were not called the All Blacks then - that title never came till the 1905-06 tour to UK.
The annual matches played between England, Ireland, Scotland, Wales and France were known as the Five Nations championship, or the International rugby championship from 1883 to 2000. When Italy joined in 2000 it was logical that the title for the showpiece to be generally known as The Six Nations Championship.
Ii is not widely known that in fact for over 100 years there was no such official tournament by name. The matches played were merely the annual fixtures between the British, Irish and French countries and it was only the media and fans who awarded a ‘Championship’ at the end of the season. There was no official trophy or title at stake. In 1992 official recognition came for the tournament and a trophy was awarded.
Terry Godwin, who wrote a book in 1984 on the international championship’s first 100 years, could find no definite date when public reference to a ‘championship’ was first made. Godwin believed it was near 1893 or 1894, some 10 years after annual matches had begun involving all four British and Irish teams. In the years that followed, only random mention was made to the ‘championship’ winners or ‘wooden spoon’ winners each year. And even when France was added to the list of annual fixtures for the four ‘home’ teams, it was left off published championship tables until after World War I.
The tournament has encouraged its own terminology. A ‘Grand Slam’ is the winning against all five other teams in the same season. A ‘Triple Crown’ refers to British teams winning against the other three home country teams. France or Italy cannot win a Triple Crown.
What was unique about the Hastings brothers, Gavin and Scott, when they made their debuts for Scotland?