Thinking and talking about rugby every day for 50+ years
You are here: Home » The Half-Term Report: The All Blacks Haven't Got out of 1st Gear Yet!
8 September 2014
I watched Serena Williams play Caroline Wozniacki the other day in the women's final of the US Open tennis championship. Williams was trying to climb to a new total of 18 wins in Grand slam tournaments. And she did do it - but the alarming thing fpr the world game of tennis was that in such a major sporting moment in her year she didn't have to move into overdrive or fast forward or maximum exertion to succeed. The All Blacks this year are on a run which looking is a bit the same. Which raises the question; Is that a good thing?
Williams won comfortably in straight sets. I kind of feel the same about the 2014 All Blacks so far. Like Serena in her tennis year the All Blacks haven't won everything (the 12-12 draw with Australia in Sydney stopped that) but they confortably retain the number one ranking in the world. No one is really challenging them. The 12-all draw the All Blacks suffered was exposed a week later as an aberration to say the least (it was followed by a 51-20 win in Auckland to McCaw's team)
But yet there is always plenty to talk about concerning the All Blacks. It's the way we are in New Zealand. They are 'our team' but there are so many aspects we always like to question mark and query. So, seeing my opinion is at least as valid as the next man's in the bar, the backyard or on the bus, here I go with mine;
September 2014 sees the one-year-to-go signpost go up around the world. So that raises questions. Are we in good shape to defend the famous trophy?
Overall you'd have to say 'yes, we're OK' but in some areas there are concerns which might turn into our greatest fears.
LET'S LOOK AT THE PLAYERS:
Israel Dagg - he is not as electric as he was. He must sharpen up or else Ben Smith has to be back there as number 1 choice. To be fair the games I have seen Dagg play in recent weeks have been in the rain - noyt always a good place for an outer back to shine.
Ben Smith - Love this guy. Runs like the wind; he has great intuition running forward about how to get through the gaps. And he feeds others in sweeping moves unselfishly at all times.
Cory Jane - Not the same since he crocked his leg last year. His pace is not electric anymore. The tries he scored at Eden Park look good but he is 'over the hump' in his career I'm afraid.
Julian Savea; One of the most markedly improved players in the world. Last year I feared he was good but the very top level might elude him. I thought he had a chink - that he couldn't kick. But now this season, at least with the kick and chase he has perfected, he has developed a further winger's weapon to now send him down the road towards greatness. Cory Jane was once on that same road but for him now reaching that goal seems out of reach.
Ma'a Nonu - One of my all-time favourites of the modern All Black story. Is it my imagination though that his best rugby is now behind him? He is not playing with the absolute authority of yore. To often his talent is overwritten by dumb charges outside the law. But good luck to him for the battles ahead trying to regain his best touches.
Ryan Crotty - You've got to like the cut of this man's jib and also his beard. While perhaps not being a first pick he is a solid man to have around to perhaps always be there off the bench.
Aaron Cruden - Neat, nice, tidy, and brilliant at times.
Beauden Barrett - Neat, nice, tidy and brilliant at times. Now where have I heard that before? The problem Coach Steve Hansen has is a good one. Whichever he picks as his first-five he has a good one. And Hansen has it correct. Start with Cruden and finish with Barrett off the bench. That many not go down too well in New Plymouth but for the All Blacks it is best. Cruden is solid and aggressive at the start of a game. Then Barrett's brilliance comes in as a real boost when the opposition are sagging in the last quarter. They're the perfect mix at the moment.
Colin Slade - Definitely the third pick for first-five but as good one if anyone ahead falls over.
Daniel Carter - Not seen in the test scene yet but he cannot be out of the mix Surely. Maybe when he comes back he will venture towards the number 12 jersey?
Aaron Smith - Another really big halfback improver but why oh why does he diminish his stature during a game by repeatedly raising his palms upwards in pleas to the referees to award penalties. The Pom halfbacks used to all do that and we hated it when we saw it. Take that arrogant angle out of your game Smithy and you will be a better man.
Tawera Kerr-Barlow and T.J.Perenara - good players both but the gap to Aaron Smith is significant. A slight worry this a year out from the World Cup?
Kieran Read - In all aspects of the game of All Black rugby this year he is a leader. I bet Messrs Hansen and McCaw are very pleased to have him around. I once wrote a piece and based it on a dream I (never actually) had (but said I'd had it!). It told of Read holding up the Rugby World Cup in triumph after the final in Twickenham in 2015! Richie McCaw was taking lots of hits and suffering concussion when I wrote the piece. And he didn't make it to the competition. If that nightmare was to happen then Read would be excellent to take over.
Richie McCaw - Not that I want McCaw out of it. Far from it - but he is still taking hits from the hard men of opposing teams. To the point where you wonder still whether he can hold together. I hope so. This year I admire McCaw most so far for his outright toughness on the field. He is amazing to come back repeatedly to make his mark from the hits he takes.
Jerome Kaino, Liam Messam and Stephen Luatua - The blindside flank position is still very much up for grabs. Messam has fallen back a bit with some recent handling lapses but just when you're about to suggest he gets the 'heave ho' from the team he scores a great try and you can see again why he is in the squad. Kaino and Luatua have to regain full fitness before they can be finally judged.
Brodie Retallick and Sam Whitelock - A great complimentary locking pair. I did have doubts about Retalick a year back but not now. And Whitelock is the goods. His shorts get pulled around in all the ruck and maul tussles he has and his lucky stripey undies are always exposed. Good stuff! They are a great pair - like Pinetree and Stan Meads were all those years ago.
Jeremy Thrush - Came on v Argentina and got stuck right in. It looks like those years in waiting are about to pay off with some longevity in the team.
Wyatt Crockett and Owen Franks (followed by Ben Franks and Charlie Faumuina) - all doing great work in the tough, murky world of the front tow. From my seat in the stands and the TV lounge I can never work those guys out. But our scrum is at least holding its own so in the dark they must be doing a good job don't you think? Both our on-field props also do great things as tacklers.
Dane Coles - another of the really big improvers from the very high hooking and loose play standards he has set in recent years. This hooker is so good the TV commentator Grant Nisbett claims him (as a fellow Poneke clubman) but so do I (Coles also went, as I did many moons ago, to Wellington College). That's how much we like him now.
Keven Mealamu - which leaves this position as a serious worry. Old 'Kevvie' has done great service dating back to 2002 but he will be 36 when the next World Cup kicks in. That's far too old - so the selectors have to find a solid back up for Coles in the number 2 jersey. Even if it has to be one of the props (one of the Franks?) who is re-trained to do the job. But then again I reckon they'll stick with Kevvie. (I bet he votes for Winston Peters in the New Zealand election - to confirm he'll get the Super Gold Card soonest - he'll still probably be in the team when he's 65!)
REMAINING GAMES FOR THE ALL BLACKS IN 2014:
13 September v South Africa in Wellington
27 September v Argentina in La Plata
5 October v South Africa in Johannesburg
18 October v Australia in Brisbane
2 November v USA in Chicago
9 November v England in London
16 November v Scotland in Edinburgh
23 November v Wales in Cardiff
(...Then it is some weeks of rest before the Rugby World Cup year of 2015 arrives...)
He lived most of his life in the far flung East Coast of the North Island but grew to be honoured all over the rugby world.
OLYMPIC GAMES RUGBY
The advent of the Rugby World Cup in 1987 seemed to silence the calls which had surfaced from time to time for the return of rugby union for the fifth time to the programme at the modern Olympic Games.
Three countries took part in the rugby competition at the Paris Games in 1900, France beating Germany, 27–17, in one match and Britain, 27–8, in the other. Most of the British team came from the Moseley club. Its loss to France may seem a surprising result, given the modest standard of French rugby at that time, but the British players had spent 24 hours traveling from London before match day and were reportedly exhausted. France was awarded the gold medal, Germany the silver and Great Britain the bronze.
At the fourth Olympic Games in 1908 in London, only two nations took part: Australia, which was touring Britain at the time, and Britain itself. The English county champion side of that season, Cornwall, was chosen to represent Britain. Australia won 32–3 at White City Stadium in London.
At Antwerp in 1920, at the first Games after World War I, the underdogs, the United States, won the gold medal, beating France in the final by 8–0. The French team had been the favourite to win, as five of the team had recently appeared in the Five Nations championship.
In both 1908 and 1920 only two teams had entered the games, but in 1924 in Paris a proper, if small, tournament took place. Most publications claim that France beat Romania 61–3 (although the French records say 59–3). The United States also beat Romania, by 37–0. In the final the United States met France.
The game was a classic, which the Americans won, 17–3. More than 30,000 French spectators watched in alarm as their team suffered such a humiliation at the hands of the Americans (many of whom had never played rugby before). As the end grew nearer and the result was inevitable, the Americans were jeered by the crowd and one visiting supporter was knocked out after being hit in the face with a walking stick. At the medal ceremony, the playing of the United States’ national anthem was drowned out by the booing and cat-calling of the crowd. Police protection was needed for the departure of the American team from the Stade Colombes.
Before the 1928 Games there was a vote by members of the International Olympic Committee over whether rugby should be included at Amsterdam. IOC members were inclined towards individual events rather than team sports, and there was also a demand for a greater opportunity for women to take part. There was a theory, too, that the British rugby-playing countries did not strongly endorse the sport’s continuation at the Games. One of rugby's greatest supporters on the IOC, Baron Pierre de Coubertin of France, had retired in 1925.
The vote was lost, and rugby never regained an official place at the Olympics. In the 1936 Summer Olympic games in Berlin, the so-called 'Hitler Games' rugby was included again, but as a 'Demonstration' sport. Four countries took part; Germany, Italy, France and Romania. France beat Romania 19-14 in the final.
In the years ahead a number of countries expressed support for the 15-aside version of rugby to return to the Olympic programme. There were especially strong attempts in 1980 (endorsed by the Soviet Union) and in 1988 (endorsed by South Korea) to have rugby re-admitted to the Games programme. Both attempts failed.
A significant moment for rugby next came in 1994 when the IRB was endorsed into the Olympic movement as a full sporting member.
In 2002 the International Rugby Board, encouraged perhaps by the presence of an ex-Belgian rugby international, Jacques Rogge, as the new IOC President, rugby tried again but this time with the idea of sevens rugby being included for the Beijing Summer Games of 2008.
This again failed, it was said that one factor being that women's teams were not included in the IRB planning. By 2009 with a World Cup for women having been (hurredly) put in place the passage for sevens to be included in the Rio de Janeiro Games of 2016 was made easier.
This happened in October 2009 in Copenhagen when the full IOC Congress endorsed the sevens version for both men and women. In fact the first appearance of sevens rugby will be at the Summer Youth Olympic Games in Nanjing, China in August, 2014.
[Additional note; There is one player in Olympic rugby history who deserves special mention. He is Daniel Carroll, the speedy wing from Sydney, Australia, who was a gold medalist with the Australian team at London in 1908, and later settled in America. He played for the United States in the Olympics of 1920 and won a rugby gold medal for that country, becoming the first and only player to win two Olympic rugby gold medals. He was also coach of the 1924 United States team.]
Fiji played its first test match is bare feet. Until what year?